by Bo Marchionte
@bomarchionte | College2Pro.com
Published November 19, 2026, 10:16 AM

Steelers Face a Different Kind of Dangerous in Philadelphia: McCarthy Questions Whether Pittsburgh Handled Success

PITTSBURGH, PA – The Cincinnati Bengals were winning. The Philadelphia Eagles have forgotten how.

Two opponents traveling in opposite directions, yet both present a problem for a Pittsburgh Steelers team suddenly forced to confront a few uncomfortable truths about itself.

Cincinnati entered Sunday night riding four consecutive victories and left with a fifth, exposing Pittsburgh in a game that was rarely competitive. Now the Steelers head to Philadelphia, where the Eagles have lost seven straight and their season has become an exercise in damage control.

On paper, the assignment gets easier.

In the NFL, paper has a remarkable ability to catch fire.

Steelers head coach Mike McCarthy was asked Wednesday whether preparing for a surging Cincinnati team differs from preparing for a Philadelphia club buried beneath seven consecutive defeats.

His answer was less about the opponent than the calendar.

“I’ve always said it’s not who you play; it’s when you play them,” McCarthy said.

It’s a useful distinction, particularly this week.

Philadelphia’s record suggests vulnerability. Its circumstances suggest something more complicated. The Eagles are operating without quarterback Jalen Hurts and offensive tackle Lane Johnson, two players central to the identity of their offense. Joe Milton is now under center, while Saquon Barkley remains one of the few established offensive threats capable of changing a game without much assistance.

The roster Pittsburgh encounters bears little resemblance to the one Philadelphia envisioned entering September.

But desperation has its own currency in professional football. A team with seven consecutive losses isn’t necessarily dangerous because it’s good. Sometimes it’s dangerous because conventional expectations have already disappeared.

For Pittsburgh, the greater danger might be assuming Philadelphia’s problems somehow diminish its own.

McCarthy offered a more revealing answer when asked about Pittsburgh’s response to its previous loss to Cleveland.

Following that defeat, the Steelers rattled off four consecutive victories. The natural question was whether Pittsburgh could manufacture another turnaround after Sunday’s humiliation in Cincinnati.

McCarthy wasn’t particularly interested in romanticizing the earlier recovery.

“The biggest challenge in this game is handling success,” McCarthy said.

Then came the question that should linger inside Pittsburgh’s locker room.

“We won four in a row. Did we handle that?”

That’s a considerably more interesting issue than whether the Steelers can beat a depleted Eagles team.

Pittsburgh had momentum. It had confidence. It had a bye week that provided an opportunity to recover physically and prepare for Cincinnati.

And it delivered one of its most disappointing performances of the season.

McCarthy didn’t hide from the contradiction.

“We were fresh. You know, we were healthy, and came back and you know and our performance was what it was.”

That last sentence carries more weight than another round of coaching clichés about execution.

The Steelers weren’t operating on short rest. They weren’t limping into Cincinnati after an exhausting stretch of games. They had many of the advantages coaches spend an entire season trying to manufacture.

They still got dismantled.

Joe Burrow threw for 302 yards and three touchdowns in the first half alone. Cincinnati built a 24-3 halftime lead, and Pittsburgh spent much of the evening looking like a team that had mistaken its recent winning streak for evidence that its problems had disappeared.

Winning four straight can disguise imperfections. Losing badly has a way of stripping away the camouflage.

McCarthy’s question about handling success suggests he understands that distinction.

There is another uncomfortable piece of history accompanying the Steelers to Philadelphia.

Pittsburgh hasn’t won a road game against the Eagles since 1965. Different generations of players, coaches and offensive systems have failed to change that peculiar piece of franchise history.

McCarthy acknowledged the drought Wednesday, noting that Pittsburgh hasn’t won there “in a long time.”

The current Eagles might represent an unusually favorable opportunity to end it.

But consider what that actually means.

A Pittsburgh team trying to establish itself as a legitimate contender is heading into a game against an opponent missing cornerstone players, carrying seven consecutive losses and struggling to resemble the team it was supposed to become.

There won’t be much room for excuses if the Steelers fail to take advantage.

McCarthy said the coaching staff spent Monday and Tuesday reviewing individual performances, identifying fundamental mistakes and examining trends that might indicate deeper problems.

“We obviously didn’t play very well, didn’t coach very well Sunday night,” he said.

That admission matters more than any manufactured enthusiasm about bouncing back.

Pittsburgh doesn’t need another emotional response to an embarrassing defeat. It needs evidence that its previous four-game winning streak represented sustainable improvement rather than a temporary escape from its weaknesses.

The Eagles are wounded. The Bengals were rolling.

Neither condition changes Pittsburgh’s responsibility.

And that’s the darker truth surrounding Sunday’s matchup: the Steelers have already demonstrated they can win four consecutive games.

What they haven’t demonstrated is that they know what to do with success once they have it.

Philadelphia offers another opportunity to find out.

But if Pittsburgh requires an opponent to lose seven straight before it can rediscover competent football, the problem runs considerably deeper than one miserable Sunday night in Cincinnati.

Photo Credit Frank Hyatt/College2Pro.com

 

 

 

Skip to toolbar