by Bo Marchionte
@bomarchionte | College2Pro.com
Published November 16, 2026, 12:46 AM
Did The Bengals Expose the Ugly Beneath Pittsburgh’s 6-2 Record Before Blowout?
CINCINNATI, Ohio – One of the famous lines from the Big Lebowski is “sometimes you eat the bear, and sometimes the bear eats you.”
Tonight the bear was a Bengal tiger. It fed heavily on both sides of the football against the Steelers.
Cincinnati dominated in a 38-18 win to leave little doubt as the who now controls the path towards winning the AFC North.
“We didn’t get the game headed in the direction that we wanted,” Mike McCarthy stated post-game.
The Bengals preferred something more methodical, picking Pittsburgh apart one first down at a time, slowly removing the oxygen from a football game that was supposed to be a heavyweight fight for AFC North supremacy.
Instead, it became a public execution of Pittsburgh’s recent success.
At one point in the second quarter, with Cincinnati leading 17-0, the Bengals had accumulated 18 first downs. Pittsburgh had one.
Eighteen to one.
By halftime, Joe Burrow had thrown for 302 yards and three touchdowns. The Bengals carried a 24-3 lead into the locker room, leaving Pittsburgh with 30 minutes to contemplate how a promising 6-2 season could suddenly look so suspicious.
The final score, 38-18, almost felt charitable.
Burrow didn’t spend the evening trying to make every throw a highlight. He simply took what Pittsburgh surrendered, which was practically everything.
Five first downs on Cincinnati’s opening possession. A 6:04 drive that stalled inside Pittsburgh’s 10-yard line and produced a field goal.
Three points. No big deal, right?
Wrong.
That possession was a warning disguised as a minor inconvenience.
The Steelers took over with 8:56 remaining in the first quarter and promptly produced an offensive performance that suggested the bye week had been spent forgetting how to play football.
Meanwhile, Burrow kept collecting first downs like loose change.
Seven more on Cincinnati’s next touchdown march, capped by a six-yard scoring connection with tight end Drew Sample just 13 seconds into the second quarter.
Bengals 10. Steelers 0.
And the bleeding was just getting started.
Patrick Queen whiffed badly on an opportunity against Ja’Marr Chase before later delivering a solid hit. Unfortunately, one collision wasn’t going to erase the damage.
Chase finished the first half with eight receptions for 135 yards, turning Pittsburgh’s coverage into an expensive spectator experience.
The Steelers couldn’t cover. They couldn’t consistently pressure Burrow into discomfort. And when Cincinnati needed another first down, Pittsburgh’s defense seemed almost eager to accommodate the request.
McCarthy acknowledged that Burrow was operating on schedule, getting the football out quickly and working through his progressions.
“I thought Joe played extremely well,” McCarthy said.
That might qualify as the understatement of the evening.
There has been something peculiar about Pittsburgh’s success this season.
The Steelers entered Cincinnati at 6-2, riding momentum and occupying the kind of position that makes everyone feel a little smarter about the football team they’ve been watching.
But winning can be a terrific disguise.
Sunday night, Cincinnati ripped off the disguise.
Jaylen Warren couldn’t get rolling.
Aaron Rodgers couldn’t establish anything resembling an offensive pulse. Through three quarters, his passing production was so miserable that a 32-yard completion to DK Metcalf early in the fourth quarter exceeded his previous total of 27 yards.
“That’s what situational football is,” McCarthy said. “You know, you the ability to go in different directions, and you know, I think you saw that in the second half.”
Think about that.
One completion surpassed three quarters of work.
Rodgers eventually connected with Metcalf for a touchdown, the 541st of his career, cutting Cincinnati’s advantage to 31-11 with 12:16 remaining.
“Well, we kind of shot ourselves in the foot with a couple plays and couldn’t really get going,” Rodgers said after the loss.
His final numbers were 15 of 29 for 143 yards and two touchdowns. He had zero yards passing the first quarter and 25 in the second quarter.
The Bengals weren’t sweating. The game was far from winnable for Pittsburgh once the third quarter began.
“Clearly, that’s not to the standard of the Pittsburgh Steelers,” McCarthy said.
No argument there.
The ugliest moment of the evening had nothing to do with Burrow, Chase or Pittsburgh’s inability to move the football.
Steelers left guard Mason McCormick suffered a frightening-looking right ankle injury in the first half.
As medical personnel prepared to cart him from the field, teammates gathered and knelt nearby. For a few moments, the scoreboard became irrelevant.
McCormick is one of those interior offensive linemen whose value hard to replace. His work is done in the trenches, where appreciation usually comes from the men standing beside him.
McCarthy said the affection for McCormick was evident and continued into the training room afterward.
There was no definitive medical update.
It was another cruel development on an evening already overflowing with them.
And somewhere in the building, former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin was preparing for his new role on Sunday Night Football.
He spoke about Week 10 football while the franchise he once led was being dismantled in front of a national audience.
You wonder whether some part of him considered what, if anything, he might have done differently.
Maybe nothing.
Some nights the other guy simply beats the hell out of you.
The consequences extend beyond one embarrassing evening.
Cincinnati now owns the AFC North lead. Cleveland also won, and suddenly Pittsburgh’s comfortable-looking 6-2 record has become 6-3 in a division that offers precious little sympathy.
McCarthy has no interest in turning the defeat into a psychological soap opera.
“We’re not going to drive down the drama road,” he said. “It’s a waste of time. It’s a waste of energy.”
Fair enough.
But there’s a difference between avoiding drama and ignoring evidence.
The evidence Sunday night was overwhelming.
Pittsburgh arrived expecting to trade punches with one of football’s hottest offenses. Instead, the Steelers were knocked to the canvas early, spent the evening looking for their mouthpiece and never seriously threatened to get back into the fight.
Next comes Philadelphia, another road assignment with little patience for mechanical mistakes, missed tackles or offensive confusion.
Maybe this was one terrible night. Maybe the Steelers will correct their mistakes and make Cincinnati look like an ugly exception.
Or maybe the Bengals revealed something Pittsburgh has been successfully hiding beneath its winning record.
Photo Credit Frank Hyatt/College2Pro.com
